The Hawala System: A Risky Alternative to Traditional Banking
This money has to be sent in turn to many different locations in Pakistan and indeed to other countries requested by the customers in the UK. In the ideal situation where funds are flowing back and forth between Hawala centers in different countries there will be no actual transfer of cash or any other money instrument. So long as the money being sent one way equals the money being returned by different persons, no net funds are being transferred. This is the principle of moneyless transfer and effectively replicates a key part of contemporary banking practice.
The transaction initiated by Maryam and concluded by Amir’s receipt of the funds takes only one to two days or, in some instances, just a few hours. No money is moved and no IOUs are signed and exchanged by Nasir and Muhammed, as the hawala system is backed only by trust, honor, family connections, or regional relationships. As mentioned earlier all the transactions of transferwise are done with the collaboration of HDFC and Yes bank. There is a minimum amount of set for receiving foreign currency in India. Compared to all the other competing banks transferwise charges less and transactions takes place in a faster mode.
Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002
She can pay 2,000 Dirhams as the first instalment and an amount equivalent of 5,000 Dirhams will be delivered to her home immediately. The expatriate has to pay the agent two more instalments of 2,000 Dirhams each in the next two months. The seizure of gold from the diplomatic baggage at the Thiruvananthapuram International Airport early this month has exposed the hawala racket’s inextricable link to gold smuggling. Julia Kagan is a financial/consumer journalist and former senior editor, personal finance, of Investopedia.
Gold Reaches New Peak of Rs 95,435 on Trade War Concerns
These activities include money laundering, terrorist financing, and drug trafficking. The hawala system is often used for these activities because it is fast, efficient, and anonymous. While the hawala system has many benefits, it is also often abused by criminals, and this is why many countries have banned the hawala system.
Funds are transferred via a network of hawala brokers
The position of the hawala operators in each other’s books gets squared off. Soon, Mongam became a market for major vehicles, including Mahindra Jeeps. It did not create any suspicion in the beginning, but later it was found out that the jeeps were instruments for transferring hawala money. The brain behind it was a Mongam native who was also a hawala dealer.
Apart from business settlements, rarely, the funding can be from illegal means as an effort to launder money. The back payment between the hawala brokers can happen as a counter hawala transaction as well. Hawala has been made illegal in many countries, as it is seen to be a form of money laundering and can be used to move wealth anonymously. As these transactions are not routed through banks they cannot be regulated by government agencies and have thus emerged as a major cause of concern. The 1991 scam was a landmark case that brought the corruption and hawala transactions into broad daylight. This case stressed on public accountability by the politicians and public authorities.
Here the businessmen and the politicians who want to evade taxes uses this system. And after the transfer money, hawaladars settle each other on a later day. Hawaladars maintains an informal journal where they record all the debt which are to be cleared and the credit which needs to be received. Debt money can be settled between hawaladars in cash, property or providing an equivalent service. There should be no third party involved in the money transfer other than the parties and the official foreign exchange banks. Hawala has been used by some individuals and organizations to bypass financial sanctions or to evade detection by authorities.
Further the respondents contended that without any sufficient evidence court is not having any authority to order investigation, and the investigation was done properly therefore court should not interfere in the present case. Abiding to the principles of rule of law and democracy, every government agency has to perform its duties as per the law and without bias and favouritism. Further the appellants prayed that directions be given so that such evil actions on the part of the investigating agencies and their political superiors are not repeated in future. The matter has also disclosed a nexus between crime and corruption at high places of nation and it poses a serious threat to the integrity, security, and economy of the nation. The amount (based on the day’s market rate) will reach home the same day.
The agent in the Gulf provides the address of the intended receiver. And, more importantly, why do expatriates prefer to send money back home through the hawala channels? Investigators have found out that this smuggling racket has connections with more than 20 hawala rackets in the country. (iii) Transferring the black money abroad as an investment in a foreign company. If any person fails to pay the full penalty money which is mentioned in section 13 within ninety days from the issue of notice for payment of the penalty, then he will be liable to civil imprisonment under this section.
The Legality of Hawala Transactions in India
The sender gets in contact with a hawala dealer A to transfer money to another country. As soon as the money, commission, and beneficiary details are shared, the sender receives a unique secretive code. Then the hawala dealer A contacts dealer B from the recipient country.
This is because the system of indebtedness has now become a commodity itself, allowing remote transactions to take place for a number of reasons that include cost and efficiency as well as tax evasion and money laundering. The Pakistani Hawalador has different business that he conducts with a Hawalador based in Dubai, transferring his local clients’ money out of the country to relations or businesses in the Middle East (e.g. capital flight). As with any system, Hawala money transmission has many variations developed by different operators working to different degrees within or alongside the UK and International banking networks.
- In India, this transaction system is illegal under the Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA) and Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA).
- While a Hawala system is similar to the workings of a formal bank, there’s no paperwork, questioning or accountability involved.
- People expect AI tools to aid in analysing and combining data to achieve transparency.
- This is because money launderers and terrorists take advantage of this system to transfer funds from one location to another.
- The main question to be addressed was why people use Hawala transactions.
Is Hawala Legal in Dubai?
The money involved was about 18 million US dollars that is equal to Rs. 650 million. Advani, V.C. Shukla, P.Shiv Shankar, Sharad Yadav, Balram Jakhar, and Madam Lal Khurana and many others. It is definitely not legal in India as it has been declared as an illegal way of transferring money by The Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999. Prior to that, it was made illegal under The Foreign Exchange Regulation Act (FERA) Act, 1973.
Generally, the money enters a Hawala system in the currency of the sender’s country and exits it in that of the receiver’s currency. Reverse hawala is a type of hawala transaction where the money is transferred back to the original sender, usually through a different hawala broker. This is often done to avoid detection by authorities or to avoid paying taxes. There are a few illegal activities where the hawala system is used.
The other way to use the official channels to route hawala money is by exporting goods showing a price much higher than the original amount. The hawala channel is decided based on not only Gulf currencies, but also on the change in the dollar and gold rates. As soon the information is received for a transaction, a black money racketeer in Kerala or outside the state will keep an equivalent amount ready. After collecting the money from expatriates, the agent hawala agents in india deposits it in the Dubai office of the black money providers. Hawala is legal in Dubai as long as the hawala provider is registered with the United Arab Emirates Central Bank and abides by the regulations that exist. The objective of introducing this Act was to regulate the entry of foreign capital into the Indian economy.
- In addition to fees, hawaladars regularly make their profits by bypassing official exchange rates.
- This is also a parallel illegal exchange market which drives the customers out from the official foreign exchange banks.
- In modern times, communication has increased the efficiency and speed of these transactions, with Hawaladors using fax, phone and email to communicate details.
- This article explains the concept of hawala transaction, the legislations which deals with hawala and the adverse effects of it.
To encourage foreign exchange transfers through hawala, dealers sometimes exempt expatriates from paying fees. The system is also easy to use, as one only needs to find a trusted hawaladar to transfer money. In the hawala system, there is no such official channel of transferring money through bank transaction or by establishing fake companies. The transfer of money happens through hawaladars which is completely based on trust. Hawala or hewala is an Arabic origin word which means transfer or sometimes as trust.
In response to this, the United Nations has enacted regulations to try to control the hawala system and prevent it from being used to finance terrorism. The hawala agents keep a tally of the money that they owe to each other. Once the settlement is done, they don’t keep any record of that transaction, making the hawala very difficult to trace. Hawala gained prominence when the investigations into 9/11 revealed that the money was paid to the terrorists through informal remittance systems.
This system works with a network of operators called Hawaldars or Hawala Dealers. For example, in India, the Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA) and the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) are the two major legislative systems that deter the use of hawala in the country. India prohibits informal hawala transactions and people from entering into them by strictly defining the types of transactions not allowed, which include the creation or procurement of any asset outside India.